dangal realty check

[siru]

Just now, kakatiya said:

no he mentioned these characters are real.. dramatized is true for any movie, because the movie itself a full drama.  Showing her master coach as comolete idiot is utter nonsense, that dont fall under dramatisation. it comes under mis representation and fictional.

The coach part, i agree, even i felt he has been shown in bad light...but again for cinematic reasons, they needed it to revive the waning affection between father an daughter.

[kakatiya]

6 minutes ago, siru said:

vunnadi vunattu teesthe..cinema avvadu..documentary avutadi...

 

i agree. let me continue the reply

[siru]

1 minute ago, tennisluvr said:

But then why isn't the real coach of Geeta coming out in protest of this portrayal of his? 

idk..may ataniki munde chepparu emo..also, none of the audience seem to be bothered about coach  ...

[siru]

7 minutes ago, tennisluvr said:

Very good point. Movies esp. those based on sports aren't as exciting as they are normally if they stuck to reality a 100% of the time because quite honestly most of the success in reality is a product of rigorous training and discipline. Adi antha movie lo choopisthey evvadu undadu hall lo choodataniki. 

Audience esp. the Indian ones want a movie that can take their emotions on a ride, and it's a fact that we all love a feel good ending. So aa matram cinematic liberty teesukotamu tappu emi kaadu. 

exactly...Thats what differentiates a Movie thats based on real story to a documentary.

 

[kakatiya]

11 minutes ago, siru said:

 

coach is very important character,

 

while mentioning mahavir singh to be true he clearly misrepresented him as anti to coach !!!

 

what is true is there are 100s of girls who are wrestlers, athletes in rotak, haryana .. sakshi malik too is one among them.

 

showing geetas father as first to fight against all odds is little misrepresnting..

 

to be honest 90% of the movie is a representation of fiction.

 

my point here is to tell that geeta and babita are not first generation girls to participate in wrestling nor people where inclined against girls participating in sports in haryana.

this will give a bad message to foreigners that girls are looked down in game of athletics, whipe they been encouraged since the time of 1947.

 

 

[siru]

1 minute ago, kakatiya said:

 

coach is very important character,

 

while mentioning mahavir singh to be true he clearly misrepresented him as anti to coach !!!

 

what is true is there are 100s of girls who are wrestlers, athletes in rotak, haryana .. sakshi malik too is one among them.

 

showing geetas father as first to fight against all odds is little misrepresnting..

 

to be honest 90% of the movie is a representation.

 

my point here is to tell tgat geeta and babita are not first generation girls to participate in wrestling nor people where inclined against girls in sport in haryana.

this will give a bad message to foreigners that girls are looked down in game of athletics.

 

 

I agree with all of your points..but again, we cannot expect 100% facts in movies. We have to se this as an entertainment with some facts.

In the 2nd half of the movie, If the coach was shown as a very good guy and Gita not distracted by city life...do u think there is any thing that interests the audience?

 

 

[kakatiya]

14 minutes ago, tennisluvr said:

But then why isn't the real coach of Geeta coming out in protest of this portrayal of his? 

why should he be coming out and protest?

he is a professional coach and he probably even might have not seen the movie..even if he s een it , master coaches of 100s of things to be worried about. Also it will only damage his career and no amount of fight will be heald against the aucceas this movie plot had made.