Jump to content

Telugolla meedha opinion enti ra..


uttermost

Recommended Posts

1 minute ago, chittimallu2 said:

Language identity exists... thats my point. Prove me wrong

you are wrong because Telanganodu as an identity marker will emerge more powerful than umbrella Telugu identity for outsiders who refer to people from Telangana. It seems that's the obvious next political route TG has to take to separate themselves from Andhra. So even if your point about language identity may be right, your mocking Halwa by calling him telugodu will probably sound stupid on hindsight, few years from now.

As for Halwa, his point of view is very narrow. Its basically territorial consolidation after a grand victory. Telling the world that the identity is separate, and asking them to get used to it. His justification about languages emerging from regions is at best tenuous, and stretching the argument too far. What he's engaging in is pure politics. and its perfectly fine.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, uttermost said:

you are wrong because Telanganodu as an identity marker will emerge more powerful than umbrella Telugu identity for outsiders who refer to people from Telangana. It seems that's the obvious next political route TG has to take to separate themselves from Andhra. So even if your point about language identity may be right, your mocking Halwa by calling him telugodu will probably sound stupid on hindsight, few years from now.

 As for Halwa, his point of view is very narrow. Its basically territorial consolidation after a grand victory. Telling the world that the identity is separate, and asking them to get used to it. His justification about languages emerging from regions is at best tenuous, and stretching the argument too far. What he's engaging in is pure politics. and its perfectly fine.

I only called him telugodu because it irks him

You didnt prove my statement wrong yet. in fact you actually agreed with me

Link to comment
Share on other sites

29 minutes ago, chittimallu2 said:

Language identity exists... thats my point. Prove me wrong

and people who don't speak majority language are treated as stateless and eventually identified by their caste and religions but not the majority language which seems that language identity exists just that it does not hold good every where...in few cases in peninsular India and people thinks it hold good all over...

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, Android_Halwa said:

and people who don't speak majority language are treated as stateless and eventually identified by their caste and religions but not the majority language which seems that language identity exists just that it does not hold good every where...in few cases in peninsular India and people thinks it hold good all over...

  

Finally you learned something today

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bhumi mundu puttindi , basha tarvatha puttindi .... ..people migrate to different places ,some influence and some adopt,

for ex urdu is so prominent in hyd region because of the nizam rule  , even British moved to different parts and promoted English.

in the reverse case , lot of people move to different parts and adopts to their cultures , USA is a great example for this , lot of immigrants moved here and developed and adopted to a culture.

so a person identity should be based on region for convenience  , lot of languages in the world are closer to extinct due to migration and globalization . 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 hours ago, chittimallu2 said:

No I didnt make it up.. Im referring to people's identities. Halwa emannadu? there is no language identity ani.. and im saying thats wrong..

Im saying that probably UP and MP lo there is no strong single language to name their state after emo ani? How is that logic superficial? The majority of UP and MP people speak hindi just like few other states and they cant name every hindi speaking state as hindi pradesh or hindi nadu etc kada? 

You might have randomly heard someone say keralite or andhrite, I didnt say that word doesnt exist but i said we being called as telugus or them as mallus is more often... 

More than anything halwa is crying that he wants a special identity away from andhra people so he wants regional identity to dominate but that doesnt happen as all the names are after languages and in most cases people will referred to based on what they speak.

I agree with you bro! But, tamil nadu antey aravam lo tamil plus naatu or naat antey dani ardham rastram ani . Where all tamil people identify themselves. Keralite ane antaru max . Mallu ane word e madhya oka 5 years popular indhi. Indhaka evaro anaru telugu nad lu anam manam telugolam kani telugunata antam . Same like tamil nat. We cant call our selves a s telugu nadu. Adhi tamil nunchi vachinatlu untundhi. More over chennai mana pere pettukunaru vallu. Malayalais manalni telungu or andhra kari antaru antey andhra vallu ani. Chala takuva mandhi asalu tg gurinchi telsu asalu chala mandhi ah word kuda telidhu common people. Telugu matladithey tamilolu “ macha ne andhra karan dhana ivan romba pana kari antaru. Baga dabulu unavallu ani vallaku adhi oka general perception. Anthey. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

25 minutes ago, lenova said:

Bhumi mundu puttindi , basha tarvatha puttindi .... ..people migrate to different places ,some influence and some adopt,

 for ex urdu is so prominent in hyd region because of the nizam rule  , even British moved to different parts and promoted English.

in the reverse case , lot of people move to different parts and adopts to their cultures , USA is a great example for this , lot of immigrants moved here and developed and adopted to a culture.

so a person identity should be based on region for convenience  , lot of languages in the world are closer to extinct due to migration and globalization . 

There's no hard and fast rule.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...