Aasti pampakaalu

[Smarty_1]

1 hour ago, Vaampire said:

Equal share is fair deal in my opinion.

Mee alkali ichina dowry anni count chesi amey share kinda add chesi overall 50% is reasonable

Haha what if that property was bought       from the earnings of sons income and are under mom and dads name??

eppudu sister vachi adi dad sampadinchinde ante ela.. ee sisters ki pelli appudu ivvalsindi ichaka y this drama now??

if parents are taken care when they are old they can give it to their daughter lekapothe not required 

[MRI]

1 hour ago, hotlantian said:

When you are happily enjoying in US atleast you have a sister taking care of your sick mother be happy for that. 

Happily enjoying in the US? You don't know what his situation is and the definition of happy is perspective. Did his sister go through the troubles of this guy to get to this situation or was she happily enjoying the emotional and financial support of family and culture back home? You don't know the trauma this guy may have went through with his father's loss and mom's suffering. Final days dad tho gadipundadu. Will he get back that opportunity now? last eppudu choosaado paapam.. Because this guy got settled, his parents may have got a moral boost and was possible to give her sister a happier life? evari kashtaalu vaallaki vuntaayi.. ilanti argument not right. 

[MRI]

8 minutes ago, Smarty_1 said:

eppudu sister vachi adi dad sampadinchinde ante ela.. ee sisters ki pelli appudu ivvalsindi ichaka y this drama now??

 

adi pedda vaallaki vundaali.. also you can show that easily and claim that share as well.. again, each person has diff preferences but just saying if you really need this share

[Fish]

1 hour ago, cloud said:

Its all dad earned properties.I am ok to have divided with ancestors property . Does my dads property not go to my mom if she is alive . Mom and my babai is also against the ask of my sister 

 Don’t we have equal rights? Enduku ammayi ante Chinna chupu

[MRI]

Just now, Fish said:

 Don’t we have equal rights? Enduku ammayi ante Chinna chupu

neeku daantlo chinna choopekkada kanipinchindi?? A women shouldn't get a share analedu. Pelli appudu pettalsindi pettesaamu. She got her share antunnadu.

[jamesbond]

28 minutes ago, iddaritho said:

I am not a lawyer but have a lot of information

did your dad wrote a will ? 
 

yes or no 

if yes follow the will 

if no you , your mom and your sister will get equal share that is 1/3 legally 

if all the property is in your moms name than she can decide what to do  neither you or your sister have any rights 

 

how much is property value , if less than 5 crore give half 

If 10 crores talk  about 2/3  1/3

 

if more than 50 crores fight 

you will never earn that money being employed by others 

 

 

 

well said... Nen mass ga cheppindi meeru class ga neat ga chepparu 👍

[Fish]

5 minutes ago, MRI said:

neeku daantlo chinna choopekkada kanipinchindi?? A women shouldn't get a share analedu. Pelli appudu pettalsindi pettesaamu. She got her share antunnadu.

He can deduct that and give her rest of the share kada…i am not sure what is his situation but mostly girls ki pellapudu they give only minimal

[Smarty_1]

13 minutes ago, MRI said:

adi pedda vaallaki vundaali.. also you can show that easily and claim that share as well.. again, each person has diff preferences but just saying if you really need this share

Pedda vallu explain chestaru but issue antha varaku vachindi ante no one cares between right or wrong ani ardam..

[MRI]

6 minutes ago, Fish said:

He can deduct that and give her rest of the share kada…i am not sure what is his situation but mostly girls ki pellapudu they give only minimal

nuvvochi ammayantey chinna choopenduku ani allege chesaavu.. daaniki response ichaanu.. daanni vadili pettesi share value gurinchi antunnavu choodu.. show me one response out here who claimed he shouldn't give a share because his sibling is a woman.. 

none of us are in that situation.. atanu mottam pelli appudu ichesaam antunnadu.. ivvaka poyina ippudu vachi exact 50-50 adugutundani complain.. pelleppudu minimal bongu istaaru.. depends on love or arranged. but typical ga ammayilu teesukuntaaru, not all. 

 

[MRI]

10 minutes ago, Smarty_1 said:

Pedda vallu explain chestaru but issue antha varaku vachindi ante no one cares between right or wrong ani ardam..

we don't know his family situation bro.. pedda vaallu vunnaro ledo.. father's might be an unexpected death and his mom is suffering and do not have the energy to deal with it.. tanu already cheptunnadu kada.. mom and uncle against her sister ani.. personal situation inka.. story ento asalu and how far is this guy willing to go.. sibling ee kada poniley ani vadilesey vallamu vuntaamu.. tana choice of life manam dictate cheyyalem kada.. if he has a little more concrete intent, we can advise what his options are..

[Vaampire]

37 minutes ago, Smarty_1 said:

Haha what if that property was bought       from the earnings of sons income and are under mom and dads name??

eppudu sister vachi adi dad sampadinchinde ante ela.. ee sisters ki pelli appudu ivvalsindi ichaka y this drama now??

if parents are taken care when they are old they can give it to their daughter lekapothe not required 

TS clearly told it's dad's earnings ani. Ippudu valla mom health balekapothey valla akka choosukuntundi ani kooda cheppadu.

 

Pelli chesi pampisthey ayipoyinattu ena? Em thinking saami idhi. Ee generation lo kooda inka asthi antha kodukulaki ivvali, koothurlaki katnam ichi pelli chesi vadilinchukovali antey manaki Taliban ki pedha Theda undadu. Daughters deserve equal share as sons. Okkavela son money tho parents Peru meedha property kontey adhi clear cheppi thisukovala. Daani meedha sisters vaata adagatam thappu. It's not the case here

[Vaampire]

9 minutes ago, MRI said:

nuvvochi ammayantey chinna choopenduku ani allege chesaavu.. daaniki response ichaanu.. daanni vadili pettesi share value gurinchi antunnavu choodu.. show me one response out here who claimed he shouldn't give a share because his sibling is a woman.. 

none of us are in that situation.. atanu mottam pelli appudu ichesaam antunnadu.. ivvaka poyina ippudu vachi exact 50-50 adugutundani complain.. pelleppudu minimal bongu istaaru.. depends on love or arranged. but typical ga ammayilu teesukuntaaru, not all. 

 

Athanu motham pelli appudu ichamu Ani ekkada cheppadu? Adhi nee interpretation. Valla in-laws adiginantha baney icham Ani cheppadu. For suppose valla dad asthi 100 crores. Valla sis ki baney antey okka 10c katnam icham antey. Rendu equal aa?

[MRI]

2 minutes ago, Vaampire said:

TS clearly told it's dad's earnings ani. Ippudu valla mom health balekapothey valla akka choosukuntundi ani kooda cheppadu.

 

Pelli chesi pampisthey ayipoyinattu ena? Em thinking saami idhi. Ee generation lo kooda inka asthi antha kodukulaki ivvali, koothurlaki katnam ichi pelli chesi vadilinchukovali antey manaki Taliban ki pedha Theda undadu. Daughters deserve equal share as sons. Okkavela son money tho parents Peru meedha property kontey adhi clear cheppi thisukovala. Daani meedha sisters vaata adagatam thappu. It's not the case here

 

2 hours ago, cloud said:

Did anyone had issues with sister claiming rights on properties and wants to divide it to 2 equal halfs . Pelli appdu my dad gave what ever inlaws asked with dowry as well . 
prastutham mom health kuda baledu and have a care taker who is looking after her when i am in US . My mom gets around 80k income which my sister takes and maintains the needs of my mom .

 

2 hours ago, cloud said:

Its all dad earned properties.I am ok to have divided with ancestors property . Does my dads property not go to my mom if she is alive . Mom and my babai is also against the ask of my sister 

@Vaampire

His mom has a care taker annadu.. his sister is that care taker analedu..  Rest of your comment.. there is no clarity there.. i think you are stereotyping the situation.. he did not say that his sister doesn't deserve anything.. it might also be the case that they gave all her share at her marriage.. his share is what they might have now.. pelli chesi Taliban lekka vadilinchukunnatta?? You don't know that. Families continuously support daughters.. pilladini baby sitting nunchi, pachallu, pindi vantakaala varaku.. There is no clarity even on what constituted to the additional properties.. Amma, babai against vunnaranteney ardham chesukovachu.. they might have a case and might be thinking the lady got her fair share.. 
I agree all genders are equal and I also see this is not a conflict of genders..

[Smarty_1]

15 minutes ago, MRI said:

we don't know his family situation bro.. pedda vaallu vunnaro ledo.. father's might be an unexpected death and his mom is suffering and do not have the energy to deal with it.. tanu already cheptunnadu kada.. mom and uncle against her sister ani.. personal situation inka.. story ento asalu and how far is this guy willing to go.. sibling ee kada poniley ani vadilesey vallamu vuntaamu.. tana choice of life manam dictate cheyyalem kada.. if he has a little more concrete intent, we can advise what his options are..

I never asked him to do what i said.. just telling legally u cannot win if sister goes to an extent asking for equal share ani antunna.. even if the property does not belong to his father and he provided monetary support for buying it just coz the property is under his parents name

[MRI]

5 minutes ago, Vaampire said:

Athanu motham pelli appudu ichamu Ani ekkada cheppadu? Adhi nee interpretation. Valla in-laws adiginantha baney icham Ani cheppadu. For suppose valla dad asthi 100 crores. Valla sis ki baney antey okka 10c katnam icham antey. Rendu equal aa?

I agree.. mottam ichaadu anedi naa interpretation ayyundochu.. but the way I am also interpreting is he claims that she is asking for equal share with what is left now..

In your example, here is my argument.. you mentioned 100cr property.. is it at the time of marriage or now? At the time of marriage, his property must have been 20cr only but now with inflation and proper investments, it might have grown to 100cr.. remember, this guy never had access to that 20cr money while his sister had instant access and could have benefited or lost after that.. it is her individual life.. andaram family kada antey dowry teesukuney route vellundoddu.. whether the property grew afterwards or whether she got lowballed anedi personal situation ani nenu antunna.. that is where family comments come into play.. may be mom and uncle have a case for their argument?