Tax contribution and Distribution of funds by individual states of India

[Android_Halwa]

11 minutes ago, reality said:

3-fold grants to their tax contribution, that UP got from center…

ekkada pothunnayi? Why those states are still underdeveloped?

Population ki tagattu ga fund distribution jariginda mari ?

The present Union-State arrangement has failed these states ani seppinaka malli vachi why these states are under developed, 3 fold grant ante inka emi septham ?

[Android_Halwa]

12 minutes ago, veerigadu said:

It’s a very arbitrary statement. Is central govt involved in the leasing of those mines currently? I thought it comes under state govt purview. 

Anyways, I’m also assuming that it’s a private enterprise that has licenses for mining in those states. Why aren’t they charging royalty from those owners? Is it a willful act of endearment to increase profits for the leasing partner. 
 

One way or the other, they can’t let this slide. Its sad if they don’t want to do it. 
 

I also won’t be surprised if most of the material is exported rather than being utilized for domestic needs. I don’t think there is any law that regulates their greed for more profits. 

Mines are national govt owned and licensed by the Union. State has least say in the awarding the mine blocks. Coal India’s lucrative coal blocks are managed by the center but not the state. State gets meager share in lucrative business. If these states have rights like the states in US, Jharkhand, Bengal and Bihar together would have crossed trillion dollar economy.

[reality]

12 minutes ago, Android_Halwa said:

The present Union-State arrangement has failed these

In what way? Ichhina funds saripothalevva? Or ee state ni union territory cheyalsi undena? CMs em peekuthunnaru mari?

Konchem clarity…

[Ryzen_renoir]

48 minutes ago, Android_Halwa said:

It’s nothing to do with land locked ness of these states. They lost their prosperity to other states. If anything has to be blamed then it’s the Union Govt. UP, Rajasthan, Bihar, Jharkhand and Bengal together supply more than 50% of the mines and minerals. If these states start charging royalty then states like Maharastra, Tamil Nadu will be left behind. For other states prosperity, these states have become poor.

UP, Bihar , bengal have close to zero mining ,infact andhra has bigger mining potential than all of those 3 combined 

The main reason is those 3 states have remained in 80's socialist era economic models till now , the population only looks forward for govt jobs 

 

[reality]

3 minutes ago, Ryzen_renoir said:

UP, Bihar , bengal have close to zero mining ,infact andhra has bigger mining potential than all of those 3 combined 

The main reason is those 3 states have remained in 80's socialist era economic models till now , the population only looks forward for govt jobs 

 

@Android_Halwa

idhi nijamena… ni fekudu nijam anukunna..

 

[Android_Halwa]

7 minutes ago, reality said:

@Android_Halwa

idhi nijamena… ni fekudu nijam anukunna..

 

West Bengal is 3rd largest in India in mineral production accounting for about one-fifth of total mineral production. Coal accounts for 99% of extracted minerals of the state, which has 11% of the total national coal reserves.

Coal: In 2015, the state's total coal reserves/resources were estimated at 31.43 billion tonnes, major coal fields being at Raniganj, Barjora etc, while coal production reached 5.33 million tonnes during 2015-16 (April to June 2015).

Deocha-Pachami Coal Block: India's largest coal mine located in the south-western part of Birbhum Coalfield in West Bengal. Spread over approximately 10 sq km, in-place reserves of coal is estimated at 2,100 million tonnes with an investment potential of Rs. 20,000 crore (US$ 3 billion).

[reality]

Just now, Android_Halwa said:

West Bengal is 3rd largest in India in mineral production accounting for about one-fifth of total mineral production. Coal accounts for 99% of extracted minerals of the state, which has 11% of the total national coal reserves.

Coal: In 2015, the state's total coal reserves/resources were estimated at 31.43 billion tonnes, major coal fields being at Raniganj, Barjora etc, while coal production reached 5.33 million tonnes during 2015-16 (April to June 2015).

Deocha-Pachami Coal Block: India's largest coal mine located in the south-western part of Birbhum Coalfield in West Bengal. Spread over approximately 10 sq km, in-place reserves of coal is estimated at 2,100 million tonnes with an investment potential of Rs. 20,000 crore (US$ 3 billion).

I thought we were talking about UP and Bihar.

No one denied the grace of WB.

[Android_Halwa]

19 minutes ago, Ryzen_renoir said:

The main reason is those 3 states have remained in 80's socialist era economic models till now , the population only looks forward for govt jobs 

In my opinion, funds distribution was never upto the mark and identifying the social indicators did not happen on a scientific scale. The figures quoted and the ground reality were completely different. Social campaigns never worked in this part of the world. 

[Android_Halwa]

12 minutes ago, reality said:

I thought we were talking about UP and Bihar.

No one denied the grace of WB.

Bihar before bifurcation was a huge supplier of iron ore. Even today it do boast of some good minerals but it’s undermined. 
 

UP is not significant as compared but Rajasthan is another mineral rich state. Mee intlo marble/granite vunte most probably it came from Rajasthan. Chattisgarh is another mineral rich state so is Orissa. 
 

All the mineral rich states are performing below the national indicators, what do you think the reason could be ? State CM’s, BJP, Modi, corruption etc lanti classic reasons ae na leka inkemaina vunaya ?

FYI, India’s Industrial Revolution started from these states and mining was the background. Heard about Jamshedpur ? Bokaro , Rourkela, Dhanbad, Bhilai, Bokaro, Burnpur, Raigarh, Jharsuguda etc….These regions collectively account for more than 50% of India’s steel production and look at their social indicators, below the national average. Endukantav ? 
 

[reality]

1 hour ago, Android_Halwa said:

Bihar before bifurcation was a huge supplier of iron ore. Even today it do boast of some good minerals but it’s undermined. 
 

UP is not significant as compared but Rajasthan is another mineral rich state. Mee intlo marble/granite vunte most probably it came from Rajasthan. Chattisgarh is another mineral rich state so is Orissa. 
 

All the mineral rich states are performing below the national indicators, what do you think the reason could be ? State CM’s, BJP, Modi, corruption etc lanti classic reasons ae na leka inkemaina vunaya ?

FYI, India’s Industrial Revolution started from these states and mining was the background. Heard about Jamshedpur ? Bokaro , Rourkela, Dhanbad, Bhilai, Bokaro, Burnpur, Raigarh, Jharsuguda etc….These regions collectively account for more than 50% of India’s steel production and look at their social indicators, below the national average. Endukantav ? 
 

Nuvvu em cheppadalchu kunnavo neeku clarity thechuko first…

Yes, India’s industrial revolution started and flourished in early days… but, ippudu BJs emi cheyatledhu antunna… you also acknowledged it… 

But, malli Bodi gadike support chesthav… at the end. okati adigithe inkoti ki digress chesthav… moving goal posts..,

[JackSeal]

3 hours ago, dasari4kntr said:

horticulture, aquaculture, vertical farming, hydroponics, aquaponics…etc

For example in telangana above 85% farmers are marginal. All the above cheyadanki financial bandwidth akkada untadhi 

[Ryzen_renoir]

6 minutes ago, JackSeal said:

For example in telangana above 85% farmers are marginal. All the above cheyadanki financial bandwidth akkada untadhi 

Even the so called rich farmers cannot afford to do such things without govt help because agriculture in general is extremely low margin profession 

It's almost impossible to even buy agricultural land with agricultural income nowadays 

 

[dasari4kntr]

31 minutes ago, JackSeal said:

For example in telangana above 85% farmers are marginal. All the above cheyadanki financial bandwidth akkada untadhi 

 

23 minutes ago, Ryzen_renoir said:

Even the so called rich farmers cannot afford to do such things without govt help because agriculture in general is extremely low margin profession 

It's almost impossible to even buy agricultural land with agricultural income nowadays 

 

paina nenu cheppinavi…just concepts..veetiki kooda normal agricultural ki entha avutundi ante avutundi…may be initially it cost more like one time setup…

agriculture ante okka paddi maatrame kaadu kada…you can grow many varieties…

in fact some of these things will reduce the dependency on agriculture land…

for example like aqua ponics or hydrapobics…etc instead of spending money on agriculture land…that money you can invest on initial one time setup…vertical farming is just an extension to the ponics culture….and also you dont have to depend on weather…

i saw some young farmers are already doing this in india…and succeeding…some are doing this in house terrace too for their own consumption…

agriculture ante land, fertilizer, karif rabi seasons, labor…etc ee traditional thinking ee povali…govt also should encourage these things …because it will become next level కుటీర పరిశ్రమ…

weather wise , money wise, eco friendly wise…these things are much better than traditional agriculture….

these things nit only for rich formers…if this concepts understood well.. anyone can do with in their own creativity …

the below are my experiments to understand these concepts well..

 

and another one…growing lettuce with out soil..

 

[veerigadu]

3 hours ago, Android_Halwa said:

Mines are national govt owned and licensed by the Union. State has least say in the awarding the mine blocks. Coal India’s lucrative coal blocks are managed by the center but not the state. State gets meager share in lucrative business. If these states have rights like the states in US, Jharkhand, Bengal and Bihar together would have crossed trillion dollar economy.

Mines are many types. Are you referring to only coal mines? But we also have mineral-based and sand based mines. For instance, obulapuram was leased to Gali brothers by YSR. Anyways, you may want to read this article 

https://m.economictimes.com/who-is-the-owner-of-minerals-in-india/articleshow/1519631.cms

[San_K]

7 hours ago, Ryzen_renoir said:

Direct tax contribution by each state in percentage 

 

Out of every ₹100 that a state pays in direct tax, how much direct tax does it get back

Union territories figures are not included 

KA > TN > Telugu States in terms of contribution to India.. I didn't expect KA to be that big. 

Mana side population ekkuva, tech ppl ekkuva..still we are contributing way lesser than KA.

E thokkalo dhaniki KTR gaadu Modi meedha crying.. Nizam langa buddhulu anni veedi family key vunnayi.